Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Finger Lakes Premier Properties has the largest selection of Finger Lakes vacation rentals and lakefront homes for sale in the region. Our properties are all waterfront homes and range from cozy cottages and cabins to luxury vacation homes for sale and rent. Whatever your interests and budget, we are confident you will find a great Finger Lakes vacation home to rent or buy.

Whether it's a 5 star with a hot tub, sweeping verandas with top-of-the-line amenities or a quaint fishing cabin in a sheltered cove, we have the Finger Lakes rental you're looking for.
Services
Finger Lakes Premier Properties is a team of rental & real estate professionals supporting the largest provider of vacation rental properties in the region. Our team has represented the Finger Lakes for over ten years. We take particular pride in providing a wide selection of lakeside vacation homes for sale or rent.
Finger Lakes Premier Properties (FLPP) is the leader of the region's vacation rental and real estate sales industries. We manage, sell, and support the highest quality lakefront properties. Our team of talented and engaged employees are committed to delivering the highest quality services. FLPP is a great place to work and conduct business.
At FLPP our staff is our most important asset to our company. We value our staff and in return, they find high value in being part of the most successful lakefront vacation rental and real estate team in the Finger Lakes. Brian Zerges is a Licensed Real Estate Broker and sole owner of Finger Lakes Premier Properties (FLPP) for the last 29 years.
Your Next Getaway Starts Here! Book Vacation Home Rentals with FLPP and Save. Find Vacation Rentals with Your Favorite Amenities: Wi-Fi, Hot Tub, Game Rooms, Waterfront Access, Neighboring Wineries and so much more! Choose from homes for large groups and pet friendly homes to make sure the whole family is on vacation.
Reviews (23)
Write a Review
Lynn Flack
Jun 22, 2022
The cottage was a delightful place for our extended family ranging in age from one year old to seventy five. Beautiful views from two separate living rooms and dining area. Kids had lots of fun in an additional theater room downstairs. Kitchen was great with modern appliances. We all enjoyed the multiple deck and patio areas along with the fire pit. Would definitely stay here again!
Amy Stemple
Jun 22, 2022
My husband and i stayed at the trottage through finger lake premiere properties. There was a tornado that came through during our stay. We lost our water. I called in the morning and management was able to send maintenance to us rather quickly to fix our problem. He was very professional and quick to fix our problem. We will be coming back soon!
Kelly Walheim
Jun 21, 2022
We had a group of 12 girls here for a long weekend and this house was perfect! There was plenty of space for everyone. The view was amazing and we loved using the fire pit and hot tub!
Krystle Ryan
Jun 21, 2022
We recently used finger lakes premier properties for a rental on seneca lake back in May of 2022. I plan a trip every year to the fingerlakes and this was my first year using this company and I will say I will be sure to use them again. We rented a brand new property which often comes with a lot of questions and they were quick to answer all. We had a few times during pur stay that I needed to reach them and they were very responsive and followed through with calls back. The property it self was beautiful and we look forward to booking our trip for 2023 with them!
Eric Olson
Jun 17, 2022
The house was amazing and exactly as pictured/described. The communication before our stay was also clear and helpful. We had a great time and will book through Premier Properties again.
Jenn Polasko
Jun 07, 2022
We used Premier Properties on the recommendation of another local business we used for a wine tour and were so happy we did. Booking our rental house was quick and easy and the representatives were helpful in providing local recommendations and responding to my questions quickly. We plan to visit the finger lakes again in the future and using Premier Properties will be our first choice for booking a rental again.
Danielle Bessette
May 17, 2022
I had an amazing experience with a rental for my 30th birthday. The property was huge and in a great location with excellent amenities. All of the information the rental company provided in advance was helpful and relevant and they were responsive to questions. Would definitely rent through them again!
Julie Cobb
Dec 05, 2021
Four of us stayed in this lovely Lakeside cottage. The views were beautiful from the dock. The walk to the dock is just a little bit steep but it is well worth the view. The home was very clean and the beds were comfortable. The location was perfect in relation to the wineries and local hiking. We had no issues during our stay. I would highly recommend staying here.
Michael Lynch
Dec 04, 2021
It is a beautiful home. However to get to it you have to drive thru a railroad tunnel that is only 6' wide and 8' tall. We were able to get our crossover barely thru it and some people had racks on top of their vehicles and couldn't get thru. They were parking before the tunnel and carrying their luggage and equipment to their cottage. The owner of the property people parked on were very angry and accused the people of trespassing.

Nice way to start a vacation. The interior of our house was nice even though the door to the stove fell.off, you couldn't watch TV and use any other devices and the last half of the 20' docks was so wobbly you couldn't walk out on it. We would not rent this place again and can't in all honesty recommend it unless some serious renovation has been done.
Steve Harshman
Nov 26, 2021
We had a wonderful stay on Lake Keuka. The house was very nice and the property was well appointed and very clean when we arrived. It had everything our party of six adults needed for a comfortable long weekend. After we booked our stay, direct contact with Finger Lakes Premier Properties was not required as everything exceeded our expectations.
AmyandMark Maslek
Nov 24, 2021
We were in town for my son's wedding and needed a base of operations. We were able to bring our dogs so that worry was alleviated. The house was roomy and clean with plenty of beds, a beautiful kitchen and a nice bath. Would love to come back and enjoy the lake and kayaks a little more. Thank You!
Tom Ott
Nov 21, 2021
The house was clean and nice. The bedroom in the basement was nice but It was a little disappointing that you could only get to it by going outside from the main house. The heating was very uneven. Still we had a wonderful time.
Lynn Salatti
Nov 18, 2021
Finger Lakes Premier Properties worked with me throughout Covid to reschedule our stay twice. They answered questions promptly and comprehensively. Their property choices are excellent and I highly recommend them.
Tami Foltz
Nov 15, 2021
Our accommodations were perfect! The cottage was so nice, clean, peaceful, and well equipped. We had an absolutely wonderful time and will come back again!
Marvin Kimmel
Oct 07, 2021
Very poor service to renters BEWARE! FOXX COTTAGE Seneca Falls NY Before settling in, check the third bedroom in the walkout basement and the rest of the lower level for signs of mold. When we arrived on September 11, 2021 we noticed a damp musty odor in the basement bedroom area - bedroom three. We found green mold/mildew growing on the back of. the basement bedroom closet doors.

We also found a large section of mold (black - not green) on the concrete block wall, on the back of the water pressure tank and wood ceiling in the lower level (walkout basement) closet that houses the water softener and pressure tank. We notified the property management company, Finger Lakes Premier Properties, .
Jack Luzier
Sep 18, 2021
Responsive to renters concerns. Follow up on requests and concerns. Would rent from them again. Lakeside Getaway "Great location! Right on the water. Great restaurant, Woolies, up the road 4 miles. Very convenient to many wineries and parks."
Ken Malesky
Jun 04, 2021
We recently rented a home on Keuka Lake lake for three specific reasons. One, the views looked stunning, two, it had a fireplace, and three it had kayaks. When we arrived the directions told us to park in front of the 2 story brown garage. There was no brown garage which we later found out by angry neighbors had been painted. The main bathroom had. done black mold or something which was gross, but the rest of the house was nice.

We come to find out the fireplace they advertise has a sign" for decoration only" and can't use. We then find out the kayaks aren't there which we're advertised or we would have brought ours. The best was the dock which doesn't have the wood nailed down and I almost hurt myself pretty good/ didn't even have wine yet. The best is I can't get anyone from Premier to even return my emails to address the issues and they hide or won't post the review. Would not recommend them to anyone anymore.
Andrea Lohr Houghton
Oct 09, 2020
Lake house description didn't match what was there. Many issues throughout the house and called company but nothing was fixed. Left an honest review about the rental that wasn't 5 stars and they won't share my review. Disappointed. Back to airbandb for us.
Leah Williamson Mayne
Aug 15, 2020
We are heartbroken that the house we booked in January for a vacation with the grandparents and great grandparent and that my boys have been looking forward to all year was cancelled DAY OF TODAY - we were packed and ready to leave, had boarded the dog, my husband and I are essential workers who have taken off the week of work, and they were not. able to offer us anything other than a refund and a $500 credit for next time?!

I'm sorry but this does not compensate for our pain and suffering and the loss of our only vacation all year. I expect more from this huge agency that is obviously prospering bc all other rentals on ALL lakes this week are booked. You can't give us back our vacation, lost family time or memories and opportunity to see my 90 yo grandmother, but I do deserve more than a simple refund for a broken contract, pain and suffering.
Sarah J. Powers
Jul 24, 2020
Was excited to get a home reserved and set up for tomorrow as our Kentucky vacation was canceled due to me being a health care worker and the concerns of having to quarantine after if I left. The family was so very excited. Then I received an email. not even a phone call about the cancelation of the reservation for TOMORROW because of our 5th occupancy (after being told we were good).our 4 year old daughter by the owner. Once again here I am scrambling to find something for us next week. Very disappointed.
Debi Drake
Jun 21, 2020
Cottages not clean. Last one looked nothing like photos. room AC filters filthy, silverware holder dirty, several light fixtures didn't have working lightbulbs, landscaping looked nothing like photo in rental listing, furniture dirty. refund inadequate for 3 week rental. #neveragain
Tommy Robida
Aug 22, 2019
Great company to rent from. I have rented 3 different properties over the past 2 years from them. Very professional, clean properties and they are very responsive.
Rick & Ruth Wetherbee
Jun 17, 2019
Point Marianne was a wonderful place for our family vacation. There was plenty of room for all of us. Anthony from Housekeeping did a fantastic job in cleaning Point Marianne by himself on Saturday. It was spotless! Keuka Lake cannot be topped for views and Point Marianne has the best of the best! Point Marianne is a very homey property with lots of room to spread out and it met all of our needs perfectly!