Business Details

We are Finger Lakes Premier Properties, the largest provider of vacation rentals and lakefront homes for sale in the region. Our portfolio consists mainly of waterfront properties, ranging from cozy cottages and cabin rentals to luxury vacation homes. We are confident you will find a great Finger Lakes vacation home to rent or buy. We offer homes located on or near Canandaigua Lake, Conesus Lake, Honeoye Lake, Keuka Lake, Seneca Lake, and Cayuga Lake. We provide a variety of accommodations that can be rented by the week, by the month, or for just a few days, depending on the season. We also provide Finger Lakes vacation packages, rental specials, and long-term rental options from September to May.

Our dedicated sales team brings seasoned knowledge of buying and selling lakefront property, helping clients from investment purchases to year-round homes. We are happy to help you plan your ideal vacation in the Finger Lakes! We assist guests in planning their ideal vacation by sharing area maps, attraction guides, and local recommendations. We leverage our market expertise as the leading lakefront Finger Lakes real estate company to turn real estate dreams into reality. We invite you to experience the natural beauty, world-class wineries, and outdoor activities that make the Finger Lakes a premier destination.

Highlights and features

We offer the largest selection of Finger Lakes vacation rentals.
Our team provides seasoned knowledge of lakefront real estate.
We offer waterfront homes on six Finger Lakes lakes.
We provide long-term rental options from September to May.
Our properties range from cozy cottages to luxury vacation homes.

Website

Update Listing

Services

Vacation Rentals

We provide vacation rental homes ranging from cozy cottages to luxury waterfront properties. Located on or near the six major Finger Lakes, these rentals suit guests seeking stays by the week, month, or a few days. Clients enjoy our largest regional selection, flexible booking periods, and help planning local attractions and wine tours.

Lakefront Real Estate

Our real estate team specializes in buying and selling lakefront homes throughout the Finger Lakes region. We serve investors, families, and sellers seeking year-round homes, investment properties, or prime lakefront parcels. Clients receive seasoned knowledge, transparent guidance, and dedicated support to turn their real estate goals into reality.

Long-Term Rentals

We offer long-term rental properties available from September through May each year. These homes are situated on or near the major Finger Lakes, providing waterfront access for extended stays. Guests benefit from off-season pricing, continuous lakefront living, and the same high-quality property standards as our short-term rentals.

Vacation Packages

Our vacation packages combine Finger Lakes lodging with curated local experiences for a seamless getaway. Packages are designed for families, couples, and groups seeking accommodations plus guided winery tours, outdoor activities, and regional attraction maps. Clients save time and money while enjoying expertly planned itineraries, access to specials, and personalized recommendations from our local team.

Property Management

We provide full-service property management for owners who list their Finger Lakes homes with us. Our team handles reservations, guest check-in, cleaning, maintenance, and marketing to maximize rental income and occupancy. Owners benefit from transparent reporting, professional hospitality standards, and the peace of mind that comes with expert local oversight.

Reviews (6)

Write a Review

Lynn Flack

Jun 22, 2022 Report

The cottage was a delightful place for our extended family ranging in age from one year old to seventy five. Beautiful views from two separate living rooms and dining area. Kids had lots of fun in an additional theater room downstairs. Kitchen was great with modern appliances. We all enjoyed the multiple deck and patio areas along with the fire pit. Would definitely stay here again!

Amy Stemple

Jun 22, 2022 Report

My husband and i stayed at the trottage through finger lake premiere properties. There was a tornado that came through during our stay. We lost our water. I called in the morning and management was able to send maintenance to us rather quickly to fix our problem. He was very professional and quick to fix our problem. We will be coming back soon!

Kelly Walheim

Jun 21, 2022 Report

We had a group of 12 girls here for a long weekend and this house was perfect! There was plenty of space for everyone. The view was amazing and we loved using the fire pit and hot tub!

Krystle Ryan

Jun 21, 2022 Report

We recently used finger lakes premier properties for a rental on seneca lake back in May of 2022. I plan a trip every year to the fingerlakes and this was my first year using this company and I will say I will be sure to use them again. We rented a brand new property which often comes with a lot of questions and they were quick to answer all. We had a few times during pur stay that I needed to reach them and they were very responsive and followed through with calls back. The property it self was beautiful and we look forward to booking our trip for 2023 with them!

Eric Olson

Jun 17, 2022 Report

The house was amazing and exactly as pictured/described. The communication before our stay was also clear and helpful. We had a great time and will book through Premier Properties again.

Jenn Polasko

Jun 07, 2022 Report

We used Premier Properties on the recommendation of another local business we used for a wine tour and were so happy we did. Booking our rental house was quick and easy and the representatives were helpful in providing local recommendations and responding to my questions quickly. We plan to visit the finger lakes again in the future and using Premier Properties will be our first choice for booking a rental again.