Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Real Estate Partner in Huntington, NY
Finest Realty Rental Specialist has been serving Long Island's real estate needs since 1972, establishing itself as a trusted family-owned brokerage specializing in rental and sales properties. Our exclusive listings feature apartments, houses, estates, and commercial spaces across Huntington Village, North Shore, and surrounding areas. With Sheila Kassay's 35+ years of expertise and a team dedicated to personalized service, we provide comprehensive tenant screening, property marketing, and 7-day availability.

Our commitment to transparency includes upfront commission disclosure (one month's rent) and flexible lease terms. Recognized by Alignable and the National Association of Professional Women, we maintain exclusive access to properties not found elsewhere while serving landlords and tenants through every stage of the rental lifecycle.
Services
Apartment Rentals House Rentals Property Sales Tenant Screening Investment Properties
Details
  • Year established: 1972
Highlights and features
  • We offer 50+ years of combined real estate experience in Long Island markets
  • Our exclusive listings provide access to properties not available elsewhere
  • Personalized service with transparent commission structure (one month's rent)
  • 7-day availability for property showings and client consultations
  • Specialized expertise in Huntington Village and North Shore area rentals
What people say
Great experience Responsive agents Professional team Transparent process Successful matches
Services
Apartment Rentals
Finest Realty Rental Specialist offers extensive apartment rental options across Long Island's North Shore. Our inventory includes studio to multi-bedroom units in various price ranges with flexible lease terms. We specialize in matching tenants with properties that meet their specific needs and budget requirements while ensuring landlords receive qualified tenants through comprehensive screening processes.
House Rentals
We provide exclusive access to single-family home rentals from modest starter homes to luxury estates. Our inventory includes pet-friendly options and properties with accessory apartments. Our agents facilitate the entire leasing process, from property showings to lease execution, while maintaining strict adherence to landlord requirements and tenant expectations throughout the rental term.
Property Sales
Finest Realty Rental Specialist facilitates residential and investment property sales with specialized expertise in properties previously managed as rentals. Our agents leverage deep market knowledge to position homes for sale while maintaining confidentiality during the transition from rental to sale status. We provide marketing strategies that maximize exposure to qualified buyers through targeted advertising and professional property presentations.
Tenant Screening
Our comprehensive tenant screening service includes credit checks, income verification, and reference validation to ensure qualified occupants for rental properties. Landlords receive detailed reports with documented verification processes while maintaining compliance with fair housing regulations. We streamline the application process for tenants through clear communication and timely response protocols.
Investment Properties
We specialize in connecting investors with income-generating properties featuring existing rental histories. Our services include market analysis for investment potential, tenant retention strategies, and property management transition support. Investors benefit from our local market expertise and established network of landlords and tenants that facilitates successful property acquisitions and management transitions.
People
Sheila Kassay
Owner/Broker
Sheila Kassay has over 35 years of real estate experience specializing in Long Island rentals and sales. Recognized as Alignable's 2024 Business Person of the Year, she maintains deep market knowledge and community connections that benefit both landlords and tenants through successful property matches and long-term relationships.
Questions
What types of rental properties do you offer?
We offer apartments, houses, estates, and commercial spaces in all price ranges with flexible lease terms including month-to-month options.
Do you have pet-friendly rental options?
Yes, we maintain a selection of pet-friendly properties across our inventory to accommodate different animal companions.
What areas do you service?
We specialize in Huntington Village, North Shore, and surrounding Long Island areas from Oyster Bay to Smithtown.
How does your rental application process work?
We collect contact information, credit scores, and income verification to match tenants with suitable properties while respecting landlord requirements.
Do you offer property management services?
We provide tenant screening, marketing, and rental transition support for landlords seeking investment property management solutions.
What makes Finest Realty different from other agencies?
We offer exclusive listings not found elsewhere, 35+ years of local expertise, and personalized service from experienced agents.
Reviews (4)
Devon Schneider
Jul 12, 2021 Report
The team (Doug & Michele) at Finest went above & beyond to accommodate our needs. From viewing times after work to making sure we were able to schedule leases signing with our work day etc. Thanks to them we are going to spend our next year enjoying a beautiful home in Huntington!
Angela Shaw
Jul 09, 2021 Report
The whole crew was great! They reached out right away to respond to our interest in the rental, and accommodated us all the way through. They are warm and easy to work with, low pressure, and really responsive. This was a great experience.
Wayne Wade
May 26, 2021 Report
I would like to start by telling everyone how professional the staff is at this firm. My wife and I were looking for somewhere to live and we searched google and found this company called Finest Realty. I know a lot of people say not to go with the first place you see but, after Michelle showed us this home I would have been crazy to look anywhere else. This house feels like home, the neighbors are very friendly, and the street is quiet and close to the village!

We love this house so much we have already approached the owner about a possible purchase. If you are considering this company to help search for your next home then look no more. Finest Realty worked with our budget and assisted in making the move in process a breeze. The photos and the description online were EXACTLY what the house looked like. I give you my word you will not be disappointed!
Lisa Pintel
Mar 25, 2021 Report
Michelle and Doug got us a great rental in Centerport. They were kind and understanding of our needs. We felt very comfortable with them! I would recommend them to anyone! Thanks Doug and Michelle! Lisa and Spencer